“Where did we ever get the crazy idea that to get children to do better, first we have to make them feel worse?” – Jane Nelsen
Early in my coaching career, I was talking with a parent about their child’s coach. The parent explained that the coach ruled by fear and belittled the children, but the team won a lot of games and the kids were getting great opportunities. The parent didn’t seem alarmed.
I asked if the coach’s behaviour was acceptable.
“Not really, but he gets results.”
A year later, the same parent brought their daughter to one of my football camps and asked me to use the week to “fix” her.
“Fix what?” I asked.
“I need you to undo the damage the coach has done. She’s lacking confidence, playing tentatively and doesn’t seem to be enjoying it at all.”
What could I achieve in one week to undo years of damage? I was furious. Surely the parent could see what this coach was doing.
“You need to find a new coach,” I said. I couldn’t fix her in a week, and he would undo all my work at his first session.
“I understand, but he’s our best shot at getting into a good college, and he gets great results.”
This girl was 12.
I did my best that week to rebuild her confidence and help her cope with stress. But I knew it would all be gone within days of returning to a coach who verbally abused her and coached through fear.
Two years later, after my TEDx talk on the power of a coach’s words, that parent got in touch. Her daughter was an emotional and physical wreck. She showed signs of depression, had lost all confidence, had regular meltdowns and no longer wanted to play sport.
“You were right,” the parent said. “I should have found a new coach years ago. It’s too late. The damage is done.”
It was avoidable.
I can’t imagine how that parent must feel: the guilt, the shame, the regret at allowing her daughter to be treated so badly for the sake of a few trophies and empty promises of future success.
Nor can I imagine how powerless it must feel to watch this happen and believe you can’t do anything about it. We wouldn’t accept it at school, in dance or in music. Why do we accept it in sport?
Why do we allow it?
Why do we keep going back to this kind of coaching when we’ve seen a better way? Why won’t we stand up for our own children, just because someone gets a few results in the win column?
There is no place in coaching for adults who treat children this way. The only way to stop it is for parents to stand up, not just for the athlete their child is today, but for the person they will become.
We fail our children when we ignore the real, long-term damage of abusive coaching in exchange for short-term results. And plenty of coaches who never verbally abuse players get the same results, while also developing excellent human beings.
The belief that treating children badly is acceptable as long as adult goals are met is dangerous, and we see it across youth sport at every level. As long as the team is winning, unacceptable behaviour is tolerated, forgiven and sometimes even celebrated. It’s a sprint to the wrong finish line.

What the science says
Negative coaching delivers short-term results at best.
Stress and performance. Anyone can perform well under pressure for a short time. But research on stress and performance, often described by the Yerkes-Dodson Law, shows that performance rises with arousal only up to a point. Beyond that, it drops off sharply. Keep piling on the pressure and performance doesn’t just stall; it collapses.
Correlation isn’t causation. We tend to credit children’s success to the adults coaching them, but we should be careful. You could scream at a group of eight-year-olds for ten weeks, belittle them, pit them against each other, punish those who struggle and reward those who succeed, and still see big leaps in skill. That doesn’t mean the coaching caused it. As Nate Silver explains in The Signal and the Noise, two things can rise together without one causing the other. His example is ice cream sales and forest fires, which both go up in summer heat.
Genetics and growth. Normal development often plays a bigger role than any screaming coach. Some children develop faster than others or win the genetic lottery and perform well young. No outside force created that. It’s biology.
Brain development. A child’s brain is constantly building and pruning connections based on what they use. Use a connection often and it fires more efficiently. That’s skill. Neglect it and the brain prunes it away.
This is where a coach’s words do matter. Children who are developmentally ahead can perform the skill, get praised, and keep practising it to earn more praise. Those who struggle and are ridiculed become stressed. Their brain’s threat response kicks in and hinders performance, so the skill never gets grooved. Worse, they start avoiding the skill to escape the ridicule, and that pathway is pruned away.
Sport is a marathon. Aim for the right finish line and there’s no need to sprint. Be patient, show empathy and let sport develop what matters more than a few victories: values, life skills, habits of excellence and behaviours that serve children long after the game ends.

The long-term damage
Even if negative coaching gets results now, it harms long-term success. Biology, brain development and adaptation may explain early results, but over time the system breaks down under the stress.
Think of it like a fuel additive in a high-performance car. It gives a boost for short races, and you win a few because your car is faster. But the additive builds up in the fuel line. Eventually it clogs, less fuel gets through and, one day, the whole engine stops.
A coach’s negative words are that additive. Children process their own words and those of parents, teammates and others. Because coaches hold so much influence, their words carry extra weight. Positive words burn clean and leave no residue. Negative words build up.
They aren’t spoken and forgotten. They’re remembered and they leave marks. Over time they build up until the player no longer has a voice of their own, only the echo of the coach’s words. In the long run, those words limit performance and wreck the engine.
Are the short-term results worth that cost?
What can parents do?
Focus on the future person, not the current athlete. What do you want for your child 20 years from now? When the ball stops rolling and life takes over, will their sporting skills have become life skills? Sport has a huge opportunity to shape character and teach life skills, but only if we make that the priority rather than results.
Judge coaches and clubs by their impact on your child as a person, not by short-term results. Hold coaches to the same standards you’d expect of any adult with influence over your child.
Be your child’s advocate. Instead of stressing about playing time or team selection, make sure they’re in an environment that helps them grow into the person you hope they’ll be.
Find a coach who keeps them loving the game. Children who quit sport don’t get scholarships or professional contracts. Above all, they need to love the game and stay in it, and negative coaching usually drives them out.
Speak up if you’re worried. If you’re concerned about how a coach treats your child or others, raise it with the club’s welfare or safeguarding officer, or your sport’s national governing body. You can also contact the NSPCC helpline on 0808 800 5000 for advice.
A conversation 20 years from now
Imagine the conversation you’ll have with your child in 20 years, looking back on their sporting journey and asking whether it was all worth it. Will you be apologising for not getting them away from that coach sooner? Or will you be grateful they spent time with an amazing adult who helped them become a wonderful human being?
Were the results of a few youth tournaments worth trading for their future happiness?
Nothing will change until we become advocates for every child in the game, our own and everyone else’s. Take the long view, and choose to end abusive coaching.
We never need to feel helpless about how coaches treat our children again.






























